Symphony No. 6 in F major 'Pastoral'
Ludwig van Beethoven
Otto Klemperer / Philharmonia
1957 Stereo recordingGil's top choice. He acknowledges it's 'famously slow' but thinks it 'really does succeed in that atmosphere of tranquility.' He finds Klemperer's steady, hypnotic way works well here.
Apple Music — Symphony No. 6 within a Beethoven collection.Karl Böhm / Vienna Philharmonic
1971From what Gil considers 'maybe the most recommendable cycle.' The performance is 'very beautiful, very natural sounding' and has 'a little bit more spirit' than Klemperer.
Apple Music — Symphony No. 6 within the complete symphony cycle.Bruno Walter / Columbia Symphony
1958Known for its 'warmth and his gentleness,' which 'really comes out here.' Gil's one criticism is the storm is 'more like a small sprinkle.'
Apple MusicAndré Cluytens / Berlin Philharmonic
1960The highlight of a 'pretty good' and 'consistent' cycle. A solid interpretation with good 1958 stereo sound.
Apple MusicWilhelm Furtwängler / Berlin Philharmonic
1954 Live recording (Tara issue)Gil's possible favorite version of all. He calls it 'gorgeous' and praises the 'really dramatic' storm and tranquil final movement.